0

Is 1899 Pei Yang 50 Fen fake or real coin ?

Hello, i bought this coin and i want to know if this the real deal and the coin is genuine or its a fake one ?

 Coin weight: 13.27 grams

Diameter: 32.8 mm 

 Thickness: 1.8 mm

+ Explain to me if its real why its real or why its fake, ? 

 

Thank you very much

10replies Oldest first
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Active threads
  • Popular
  • Hello,my friend! I already explained you these(your inquiries),recently,on another site... For the same coin!

    But,if you wish to wait also for other opinions,please be my guest!

    Did you pay a large amount of money for this coin?

    Andi馃憢

    Like
      • Trox
      • Trox
      • 3 mths ago
      • Reported - view

      Andi Pasculescu  really? I am sorry i didnt notice you explain to me and can you please write again to me here your opinion of my coin and what you thinkk about it.

      Like
  • Hi again! My personal opinion is that the coin MAY BE fake and not genuine... It has an unnatural appearance for a 123 years old coin,too frosty/uncirculated! This,although the coin's weight is good and matches that given by catalogues(3.30g.)... I gave the same answer for a same topic, registered on another site but I don't find it right now. Instead,I send you the screenshot with the opinion of another coin collector,somehow different of mine.

    P.S.: Have you done the magnetic test on the coin?! Good silver NEVER STICKS TO A MAGNET! Even if the coin doesn't stick,you cannot yet be 100% sure of its authenticity but this is a good start at what number of fake coins fail! 

    Andi馃憢 

    Like
  • @Paul Richards , hello, what do you think about my coin is it genuine or fake ? According to your long experience ?

    Like
  • Trox -- I'm with Andi on this one. I believe it is a fake.

    As always, I thank Heritage for letting us use their coin photos. The one I've included here is of a genuine 25 Year of Kuang Hsu.

    The crooks in China are so good at making counterfeit coins, you can't go by the pattern or, sometimes, even the weight. But surface quality usually tells the tale.

    Buy Chinese coins ONLY from someone you know and trust.

    The surfaces of your coin look new. That's bad. According to Heritage, lightly circulated specimens of this coin are basically non-existent.

    Here is the auction write-up for my pictured coin.

    Heritage World Coin Auctions > Hong Kong Signature Sale 3100    Auction date: 7 July 2022
    Lot number: 34027

    Price realized: 5,750 USD   (Approx. 5,653 EUR / 4,791 GBP / 5,594 CHF) 

    China
    Chihli. Kuang-hs眉 50 Cents Year 25 (1899) AU Details (Scratch) PCGS, Pei Yang Arsenal mint, KM-Y72, L&M-455, Kann-197, Shih-C7-17, WS-0625. The key date within the short-lived Chihli 50 Cents series, highly coveted in all conditional states and yet scarcely available above VF. Indeed, across both NGC and PCGS, only a single Mint State piece has been graded, with the next finest being a small group of three AU58's. To date, the nicest we have offered was a VF25, which brought $3600 in our December 2017 HKINF sale. Despite the noted scratch to the left of hs眉 on the obverse (reverse as holdered) and some minor hairlines, the coin undeniably has only very lightly circulated, champagne luster fully evident over both sides with a satin texture preserved near to the devices.

    Like
      • Trox
      • Trox
      • 3 mths ago
      • Reported - view

      Paul Richards i buy this coin from ebay at 233$ , do you mean this too good to be true

      Like
    • Yes

      Like
  • Hi again ''Trox''! Sorry to give you the bad news but you have a lost of 233$ for your wallet! 

    P.S.: You never told us(me & Paul) if you did the magnet test on your coin... I wonder if it will pass that test!

    Andi馃憢

    Like
  • I also own one and it's original I think and if anyone is interested this is my number

    Like
      • Marko22
      • Marko22
      • 2 mths ago
      • Reported - view

      Medox my email: bmw_0@hotmail.com

      Send me message and we will make deal 

      Like
Like Follow
  • 2 mths agoLast active
  • 10Replies
  • 68Views
  • 5 Following